| 2004 | Phil Mickelson | 68-59--127 |
| Vijay Singh | 66-66--132 | |
| Retief Goosen | 65-68--133 | |
| Todd Hamilton | 70-75--145 |
| 2003 | Jim Furyk | 67-68--135 |
| Mike Weir | 72-71--143 | |
| Shaun Micheel | 75-70--145 | |
| Ben Curtis | 73-73--146 |
| 2002 | Tiger Woods | 66-61-127 |
| Rich Beem | 72-73-145 | |
| Justin Leonard | 69-72-141 | |
| Davis Love III | 72-69-141 |
| 2001 | Tiger Woods | 67-65-132 |
| Retief Goosen | 71-66-137 | |
| David Duval | 76-72-148 | |
| David Toms | 68-67-135 |
| 2000 | Tiger Woods | 71-68-139 (Won Playoff) |
| Vijay Singh | 69-70-139 | |
| Paul Azinger | 74-74-148 | |
| Tom Lehman | 73-70-143 |
| 1999 | Championship Match: Tiger Woods def. Davis Love III | 3&2 |
| Third Place Match: José Maria Olazabál def. Paul Lawrie | injury defeat | |
| First-Round Match: Woods def. Lawrie | 3&2 | |
| Love def. Olazabal | 6&5 |
| 1998 | Championship Match: Tiger Woods def. Vijay Singh | 2-up |
| Third Place Match: Lee Janzen def. Mark O'Meara | 1-up | |
| First-Round Match: Woods def. Janzen | 3&2 | |
| First-Round Match: Singh def. O'Meara | 2-up |
| 1997 | Ernie Els | 68-65-133 |
| Tiger Woods | 66-70-136 | |
| Justin Leonard | 77-72-149 | |
| Davis Love III | 71-67-138 |
| 1996 | Tom Lehman | 68-66-134 |
| Nick Faldo | 67-72-139 | |
| Steve Jones | 70-66-136 | |
| Mark Brooks | 74-73-147 |
| 1995 | Ben Crenshaw | 72-68-140 |
| Corey Pavin | 71-70-141 | |
| John Daly | 73-73-146 | |
| Steve Elkington | 71-70-141 |
| 1994 | Greg Norman | 70-66-136 |
| José Maria Olazábal | 74-70-144 | |
| Ernie Els | 72-71-143 | |
| Nick Price | 70-69-139 |